Judging Criteria

Stage 1: Selection from Project description (Initial screening) [Total 20]

 Excellent (5)Good (4)Fair (2)Poor (1)
SpecificClearly focused on the desired objectivePartially focused on the desired objective.Desired objective is unclear.Objective is unrelated to the assignment.
MeasurableWill be measurable because the evidence to be provided will clearly indicate progress.Will be only partly measurable because the evidence to be provided will not clearly indicate progressEvidence of progress will be provided, but will not indicate progress.Not at all measurable
AttainableThe objective is within reason of the unit’s abilities and can be achieved.The objective is mostly reasonable given the unit’s abilities and can probably be achieved.The objective is only partially reasonable given the unit’s abilities and will likely not be achieved.The objective is not at all within reason and cannot be achieved.
RelevantThe objective has a strong connection to the unit’s history, current interests and/or demonstrated abilities.The objective has some connection to the unit’s history, current interests and/or demonstrated abilities.The objective has only a slight connection to the unit’s history, current interests and/or demonstrated abilities.The objective has no connection to the unit’s life because the unit has no history or interest in or demonstrated ability to the objective.
TimelinessHas a definite date of what will be accomplished by this date. Is within the required time frame.Has an indefinite date of what will be accomplished by this date yet is within the time frame.Has an indefinite date of what will be accomplished by this date AND has an unclear time frame by which the objective should be accomplished.Has no dates and/or is over a period of time far beyond this time frame.
× How can I help you?